E-ISSN 2149-2018
 

Original Research 


Comparison of plate and nail fixation for acute humeral shaft fracture of our experience

Yi-Lune Huang, Chi-Rung Chung, Po-Chung Huang, Wei-Tin Lin.

Abstract
Introduction: Plating fixation for treatment of humeral shaft fracture is a gold standard method in old days. Due to the progression of surgical technique and implant material, nailing fixation for humeral shaft fracture seems to also be a reasonable choice. However, different outcomes are reported. Hence, we make a retrospective study of our cases to compare and analyze plating and nailing system for humeral shaft fracture. Materials and Methods: From January 2007 to February 2012, all patients who are diagnosed humeral shaft fracture classified with Orthopedic Trauma Association classification, treated with nailing or plating fixation, and complete the follow-up are collected. A total of 53 patients treated with plating and 22 treated with nailing are included. Union rate and complications are recorded. Causing and consequent management for complications are also recorded and analyzed. Results: All the patients were observed within an average of 21.7 months. Union rate of plating system in our study is 94.3% (50/53), as mentioned in established data. However, the union rate of nailing system is only 72.7% (16/22) and that is lower than we used to get from established data. Revision is applied for all three non-union patients in the plating group and three in the nail group. Open reduction internal fixation with plating and autogenous bone graft are applied for patients receiving revision, and all of them got union. Complications are as well as established data mentioned, radial nerve palsy or paresis is the main problems for plating system (6/53). Although radial nerve palsy is much less frequent happened in the nailing group, but fracture site distraction, and shoulder pain that rarely happened in the plating system take a large proportion in the nailing system. Conclusion: Plating system for humeral shaft fracture remains the most secure method as high union rate and well-known complications. Nailing systems, though gets a higher proportion to use, there are still some problems needed to be solved, especially lower union rate and operative site complications.

Key words: Humeral shaft fracture, interlocking nail fixation, plate fixation


 
ARTICLE TOOLS
Abstract
PDF Fulltext
Print this article Print this Article
How to cite this articleHow to cite this article
Citation Tools
Related Records
 Articles by Yi-Lune Huang
Articles by Chi-Rung Chung
Articles by Po-Chung Huang
Articles by Wei-Tin Lin
on Google
on Google Scholar
Article Statistics
 Viewed: 3293
Downloaded: 611
Cited: 0


REFERENCES
1. Flinkkilä T, Hyvönen P, Lakovaara M, Linden T, Ristiniemi J, Hämäläinen M. Intramedullary nailing of humeral shaft fractures. A retrospective study of 126 cases. Acta Orthop Scand 1999;70:133-6. [DOI via Crossref]    [Pubmed]   
2. Robinson CM, Bell KM, Court-Brown CM, McQueen MM. Locked nailing of humeral shaft fractures. Experience in Edinburgh over a two-year period. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1992;74:558-62. [Pubmed]   
3. Singisetti K, Ambedkar M. Nailing versus plating in humerus shaft fractures: A prospective comparative study. Int Orthop 2010;34:571-6. [DOI via Crossref]    [Pubmed]    [PMC Free Fulltext]   
4. Kesemenli CC, Subasi M, Arslan H, Necmioglu S, Kapukaya A. Comparison between the results of intramedullary nailing and compression plate fixation in the treatment of humerus fractures. Acta Orthop Traumatol Turc 2003;37:120-5. [Pubmed]   
5. Heineman DJ, Bhandari M, Poolman RW. Plate fixation or intramedullary fixation of humeral shaft fractures – an update. Acta Orthop 2012;83:317-8. [DOI via Crossref]    [Pubmed]    [PMC Free Fulltext]   
6. McCormack RG, Brien D, Buckley RE, McKee MD, Powell J, Schemitsch EH. Fixation of fractures of the shaft of the humerus by dynamic compression plate or intramedullary nail. A prospective, randomised trial. J Bone Joint Surg Br 2000;82:336-9. [DOI via Crossref]    [Pubmed]   
7. Bernard de Dompsure R, Peter R, Hoffmeyer P. Uninfected nonunion of the humeral diaphyses: Review of 21 patients treated with shingling, compression plate, and autologous bone graft. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res 2010;96:139-46. [DOI via Crossref]    [Pubmed]   
8. Marti RK, Verheyen CC, Besselaar PP. Humeral shaft nonunion: Evaluation of uniform surgical repair in fifty-one patients. J Orthop Trauma 2002;16:108-15. [DOI via Crossref]    [Pubmed]   
9. Thompson AG, Batten RL. The application of rigid internal fixation to the treatment of non-union and delayed union using the AO technique. Injury 1977;8:188-98. [DOI via Crossref]   
10. Chapman JR, Henley MB, Agel J, Benca PJ. Randomized prospective study of humeral shaft fracture fixation: Intramedullary nails versus plates. J Orthop Trauma 2000;14:162-6. [DOI via Crossref]    [Pubmed]   
11. Farragos AF, Schemitsch EH, McKee MD. Complications of intramedullary nailing for fractures of the humeral shaft: A review. J Orthop Trauma 1999;13:258-67. [DOI via Crossref]    [Pubmed]   
12. Riemer BL, Butterfield SL, D'Ambrosia R, Kellam J. Seidel intramedullary nailing of humeral diaphyseal fractures: A preliminary report. Orthopedics 1991;14:239-46. [Pubmed]   
13. McKee MD, Seiler JG, Jupiter JB. The application of the limited contact dynamic compression plate in the upper extremity: An analysis of 114 consecutive cases. Injury 1995;26:661-6. [DOI via Crossref]   
14. Vander Griend R, Tomasin J, Ward EF. Open reduction and internal fixation of humeral shaft fractures. Results using AO plating techniques. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1986;68:430-3. [Pubmed]   

How to Cite this Article
Pubmed Style

Yi-Lune Huang, Chi-Rung Chung, Po-Chung Huang, Wei-Tin Lin. Comparison of plate and nail fixation for acute humeral shaft fracture of our experience. Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): 8-11. doi:10.5455/amr.20150131071756


Web Style

Yi-Lune Huang, Chi-Rung Chung, Po-Chung Huang, Wei-Tin Lin. Comparison of plate and nail fixation for acute humeral shaft fracture of our experience. http://www.ejmamr.com/?mno=178404 [Access: November 18, 2019]. doi:10.5455/amr.20150131071756


AMA (American Medical Association) Style

Yi-Lune Huang, Chi-Rung Chung, Po-Chung Huang, Wei-Tin Lin. Comparison of plate and nail fixation for acute humeral shaft fracture of our experience. Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): 8-11. doi:10.5455/amr.20150131071756



Vancouver/ICMJE Style

Yi-Lune Huang, Chi-Rung Chung, Po-Chung Huang, Wei-Tin Lin. Comparison of plate and nail fixation for acute humeral shaft fracture of our experience. Appl Med Res. (2015), [cited November 18, 2019]; 1(1): 8-11. doi:10.5455/amr.20150131071756



Harvard Style

Yi-Lune Huang, Chi-Rung Chung, Po-Chung Huang, Wei-Tin Lin (2015) Comparison of plate and nail fixation for acute humeral shaft fracture of our experience. Appl Med Res, 1 (1), 8-11. doi:10.5455/amr.20150131071756



Turabian Style

Yi-Lune Huang, Chi-Rung Chung, Po-Chung Huang, Wei-Tin Lin. 2015. Comparison of plate and nail fixation for acute humeral shaft fracture of our experience. Applied Medical Research, 1 (1), 8-11. doi:10.5455/amr.20150131071756



Chicago Style

Yi-Lune Huang, Chi-Rung Chung, Po-Chung Huang, Wei-Tin Lin. "Comparison of plate and nail fixation for acute humeral shaft fracture of our experience." Applied Medical Research 1 (2015), 8-11. doi:10.5455/amr.20150131071756



MLA (The Modern Language Association) Style

Yi-Lune Huang, Chi-Rung Chung, Po-Chung Huang, Wei-Tin Lin. "Comparison of plate and nail fixation for acute humeral shaft fracture of our experience." Applied Medical Research 1.1 (2015), 8-11. Print. doi:10.5455/amr.20150131071756



APA (American Psychological Association) Style

Yi-Lune Huang, Chi-Rung Chung, Po-Chung Huang, Wei-Tin Lin (2015) Comparison of plate and nail fixation for acute humeral shaft fracture of our experience. Applied Medical Research, 1 (1), 8-11. doi:10.5455/amr.20150131071756





Most Viewed Articles
  • Applied Medical Research (AMR) is starting
    Editorial Team
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): i-i
    » Abstract

  • Preeclampsia at molecular level
    Randa Abdel Kader ElDesouki, Fawzia Ahmed Habib
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(2): 65-72
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150314055636

  • Maternal anemia during pregnancy in Bahrdar Town, Northwestern Ethiopia: A facility-based retrospective study
    Mulugeta Melku, Aster Agmas
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): 2-7
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150129110510

  • Design and characterization of microsponge loaded controlled release epicutaneous gel of lornoxicam
    Purnima Panday, Neha Shukla, Dharmesh Sisodiya, Vikas Jain, Suresh Chand Mahajan
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): 16-21
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150127052147

  • High Sensitivity C-Reactive Protein: Could it be used as a Cardiovascular Risk Predictor in Hemodialysis Patients?
    Sefer Usta, Hamit Serdar Basbug, Yavuz Cakiroglu
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): 12-15
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150127120710

  • Effect of a methanol extract of Allium cepa Linn. on incisional wound healing in alloxan-induced diabetic mice
    David Emery Tsala, Mendimi Nkodo Joseph, Tatsimo Simplice, Nnanga Nga, Edmond Jacques, Miaffo David
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(3): 90-93
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150427021827

  • A newborn with a missing cerebrum
    Anne Weissenstein, Gloria Villalon, Elisabeth Luchter, Stefan Bittmann
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): 37-38
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150201030834

  • A comparative study of transabdominal preperitoneal (TAPP) verses totally extra-peritoneal (TEP) Mesh repair of inguinal hernia
    Shaukat Jeelani, Malik Suhail Ahmad, Hanief Mohamed Dar, Malik Faizan Abass, Azhar Mushtaq, Ubaid Ali
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(2): 60-64
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150403124300

  • Psychometric Properties of the SF-12, Penn Shoulder Score, and Visual Analogue Scale-Pain for Rotator Cuff Retears
    Jyothi Menon, Joseph C. Cappelleri, Jack Mardekian, Nicholas J. Vendetti, Marko Mychaskiw, Joseph Thomas III
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(3): 109-117
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150701024630

  • Open peer review: An initiative to look out for
    Ganesh Singh Dharmshaktu
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): 1-1
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150128101319

  • Most Downloaded
  • Applied Medical Research (AMR) is starting
    Editorial Team
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): i-i
    » Abstract

  • A comparative study of transabdominal preperitoneal (TAPP) verses totally extra-peritoneal (TEP) Mesh repair of inguinal hernia
    Shaukat Jeelani, Malik Suhail Ahmad, Hanief Mohamed Dar, Malik Faizan Abass, Azhar Mushtaq, Ubaid Ali
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(2): 60-64
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150403124300

  • High-fat diet and low-dose streptozotocin induced type 2 diabetes: a methodological critique
    Zeynep Ozturk
    Appl Med Res. 2016; 2(2): 41-42
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20160610011150

  • Prevalence of forward head posture among 12-16 year old school going students - A cross sectional study
    Shivani Lalitkumar Verma, Jilani Shaikh, Ranveer Kumar Mahato, Megha Sandeep Sheth
    Appl Med Res. 2018; 4(2): 18-21
    » Abstract » doi: 10.5455/amr.20180805064752

  • Design and characterization of microsponge loaded controlled release epicutaneous gel of lornoxicam
    Purnima Panday, Neha Shukla, Dharmesh Sisodiya, Vikas Jain, Suresh Chand Mahajan
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): 16-21
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150127052147

  • Effect of a methanol extract of Allium cepa Linn. on incisional wound healing in alloxan-induced diabetic mice
    David Emery Tsala, Mendimi Nkodo Joseph, Tatsimo Simplice, Nnanga Nga, Edmond Jacques, Miaffo David
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(3): 90-93
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150427021827

  • Hemifacial Microsomia with bilateral ear involvement.
    ananya madiyal, VIDYA AJILA, SHRUTHI HEGDE, subhas babu, priyadharshini alva
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(4): 140-143
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150730064612

  • Determination of Minimum inhibitory concentrations of Common Biocides to Multidrug-Resistant Gram-negative bacteria
    Rajendran Vijayakumar, Mohammad Saleh Al- Aboody, Meshal K. AlFonaisan, Wael Al Turaiki, Suresh Mickymaray, Premanathan Mariappan, Suliman A. Alsagaby, Tim Sandle
    Appl Med Res. 2016; 2(3): 56-62
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20161012082036

  • Maternal anemia during pregnancy in Bahrdar Town, Northwestern Ethiopia: A facility-based retrospective study
    Mulugeta Melku, Aster Agmas
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): 2-7
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150129110510

  • Disseminated Mycobacterium scrofulaceum infection in a patient with lymphoma
    Yu-Wen Wang, Chuan-Chuan Hung, Chi-Chou Tseng, Ping-Jen Chen, Chien-Ming Chao
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(2): 84-86
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150331112559

  • Most Cited Articles
  • A comparative study of transabdominal preperitoneal (TAPP) verses totally extra-peritoneal (TEP) Mesh repair of inguinal hernia
    Shaukat Jeelani, Malik Suhail Ahmad, Hanief Mohamed Dar, Malik Faizan Abass, Azhar Mushtaq, Ubaid Ali
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(2): 60-64
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150403124300
    Cited : 5 times [Click to see citing articles]

  • Sociodemographic and Obstetrical Factors Associated with Low Birth Weight: Community Based Retrospective Study in an Urban Slum of Western India
    Prakash B Patel, Neha R Bavarva, Manan J Patel, Jayesh J Rana, Shreyash R Mehta, Rajkumar K Bansal
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(3): 94-98
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150504014512
    Cited : 3 times [Click to see citing articles]

  • High-fat diet and low-dose streptozotocin induced type 2 diabetes: a methodological critique
    Zeynep Ozturk
    Appl Med Res. 2016; 2(2): 41-42
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20160610011150
    Cited : 3 times [Click to see citing articles]

  • Determination of Minimum inhibitory concentrations of Common Biocides to Multidrug-Resistant Gram-negative bacteria
    Rajendran Vijayakumar, Mohammad Saleh Al- Aboody, Meshal K. AlFonaisan, Wael Al Turaiki, Suresh Mickymaray, Premanathan Mariappan, Suliman A. Alsagaby, Tim Sandle
    Appl Med Res. 2016; 2(3): 56-62
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20161012082036
    Cited : 3 times [Click to see citing articles]

  • High Sensitivity C-Reactive Protein: Could it be used as a Cardiovascular Risk Predictor in Hemodialysis Patients?
    Sefer Usta, Hamit Serdar Basbug, Yavuz Cakiroglu
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(1): 12-15
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150127120710
    Cited : 2 times [Click to see citing articles]

  • Open Fracture Wound Infections Caused by Aeromonas species
    Tung-Lung Wu, Chung-Da Wu, Chung-Hsing Yu, Chi-Chou Tseng, Huan-Tee Chan, Po-Yih Chen, Wei-Ming Chen, Wei-Ting Lin
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(2): 39-45
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150318032102
    Cited : 2 times [Click to see citing articles]

  • Preeclampsia at molecular level
    Randa Abdel Kader ElDesouki, Fawzia Ahmed Habib
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(2): 65-72
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150314055636
    Cited : 1 time [Click to see citing article]

  • Psychometric Properties of the SF-12, Penn Shoulder Score, and Visual Analogue Scale-Pain for Rotator Cuff Retears
    Jyothi Menon, Joseph C. Cappelleri, Jack Mardekian, Nicholas J. Vendetti, Marko Mychaskiw, Joseph Thomas III
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(3): 109-117
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150701024630
    Cited : 1 time [Click to see citing article]

  • Cutaneous tuberculosis: a clinicopathological study of 50 cases from a tertiary care referral hospital
    Rajpal Singh Punia, Phiza Aggarwal, Reetu Kundu, Harsh Mohan, Mala Bhalla, Deepak Aggarwal
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(3): 104-108
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150412074909
    Cited : 1 time [Click to see citing article]

  • Intestinal Bacteroides vulgatus showing resistance to metals
    Aline Ignacio, Viviane Nakano, Mario J Avila-Campos
    Appl Med Res. 2015; 1(2): 46-50
    » Abstract & References » doi: 10.5455/amr.20150401012721
    Cited : 1 time [Click to see citing article]